Grapeling lesson 27 · About 3 minutes

Faulty, or just not for you?

A wine can taste wrong in two ways. It can be broken, or it can just be a style you don't like. Your nose can often tell the difference.

Name the smell

A wine fault is a flaw: a smell that shouldn't be there. Four common ones. Cork taint smells musty, like a damp basement or wet cardboard. Too much volatile acidity smells like vinegar or nail polish remover. Oxidation, from too much air, smells like hay, straw or a bruised apple. Reduction smells like rotten eggs, from sulfur compounds.

A faint vinegar note isn't always a problem. It becomes a fault when it's strong enough to take over.

Go deeper

Cork taint comes from a compound called TCA, which molds can make. In one test, a tiny amount was enough to turn down the fruity smell of a wine.

Keep it safe

Faults can happen after you buy, too. Heat is hard on wine, and so are swings between hot and cold. Light also speeds up oxidation.

The best home is cool and dark, where the temperature stays steady. Bottles with a cork are usually stored lying down, so the wine keeps the cork from drying out.

Go deeper

Wine kept too warm can turn brown and lose its smell. Dark glass helps against light.

Once opened, many wines keep fairly well for a few days in the fridge. Delicate wines fade sooner.

Scary, but fine

Some things look like a problem and aren't. Tiny glassy crystals can show up in a bottle. They're tartrate crystals, which form from natural stuff in the wine. They're natural and harmless.

They form most easily in the cold, and they can show up even after the wine is bottled.

Go deeper

Some drinkers think crystals mean sugar or glass or a defect. They don't.

And a wine you simply don't like isn't faulty. Too sour, too sweet or too bitter for you is about taste. A fault is a smell that shouldn't be there.

Vinegar, apple, spot

You can train your nose on faults without any wine. White vinegar gives you the volatile acidity smell. An apple slice shows what air does.

Three questions

Wrong answers are part of it. Each one tells you why.

A fault is a smell that shouldn't be there.

If a bottle in a restaurant smells off to you, it's fine to quietly ask the server to take a look. If it just isn't your style, that's a different story.

Next up: wine and food, one step further.

Grapeling says: Trust your nose. If it smells wrong, you're allowed to say so.

Sources

Back to the lesson lab