Grapeling lesson 4 · About 3 minutes
Sweet vs dry
Fruity is a smell. Sweet is sugar. People mix them up all the time, and it changes what they order.
Dry means the sugar is gone
Yeast eats the sugar in grape juice. If it eats almost all of it, the wine is dry.
Stop the yeast early and some sugar stays behind. That's called residual sugar, and it makes the wine taste sweet.
Go deeper
In the EU, these words have legal limits for still wine. Dry: up to 4 grams of sugar per liter. Medium dry: up to 12. Medium sweet: up to 45. Sweet: 45 or more.
There's a twist in the rules. A wine with plenty of acid can have up to 9 grams of sugar and still be called dry, because the acid makes it taste drier. You'll see why in step 3.
Fruity is not sweet
A dry wine can smell of ripe peach or pineapple and still have almost no sugar.
The fruit is in your nose. Sugar is something only your tongue can find.
Go deeper
Those fruity smells are aroma molecules, many of them made by yeast during fermentation. You met them in lesson 2. They carry smell, not sugar.
Alcohol and some other compounds in a dry wine also taste a little sweet. That's one reason a dry wine can feel soft instead of harsh.
Acid hides sugar
Sweetness and acidity push against each other. Add acid and the same sugar tastes less sweet.
That's why a wine with a little sugar and lots of acid can still taste crisp.
Go deeper
Wine scientists describe the balance as sweetness on one side and acidity plus bitterness and astringency on the other. Push one side up and the other seems smaller.
Taste studies with sugar water and acid find the same thing. Acid lowers how sweet the sugar tastes, and sugar lowers how sour the acid tastes.
Sugar water, then lemon
Stir a spoon of sugar into a glass of water and taste it.
Squeeze in some lemon and taste again. Same sugar, less sweet.
Three questions
Wrong answers are part of it. Each one tells you why.
Fruity is a smell. Sweet is sugar.
If you think you don't like sweet wine, try asking for “dry but fruity”. That's often what people actually mean.
Next up: acid, the one that makes your mouth water.
Grapeling says: I once called a wine sweet for a whole dinner. It was dry. It just smelled like a fruit bowl.
Sources
- Terms indicating the sugar content of winesEUR-Lex, Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/33, Annex III Part B
- Annex III: sugar content termslegislation.gov.uk (retained copy of Regulation (EU) 2019/33)
- Matching Table Wines with Foods (B. Zoecklein)Virginia Tech, Department of Food Science and Technology
- Taste Interactions between Sweetness of Sucrose and Sourness of Citric and Tartaric AcidJunge et al., Foods, 2020 (PubMed Central)
- Role of Yeasts on the Sensory Component of WinesRomano et al., Microorganisms, 2022 (PubMed Central)